
The Marker Key West Harbor Resort
Best for families or groups who want multiple pools, on-site waterfront dining, and easy access to the Historic Seaport and water activities.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
The Marker Key West Harbor Resort is a 4-star waterfront resort in Old Town Key West with 96 balcony rooms, three pools (including an adults-only Serenity pool), and a casual waterfront restaurant — good for families and watersports-focused travelers. The Saint Hotel Key West, Autograph Collection is a 3.5-star adults-only boutique near Duval Street with 36 rooms, a rooftop terrace and a small outdoor pool — read this if you want a stylish, adults-only stay close to Key West nightlife.
Updated · about 0.6 km apart

Best for families or groups who want multiple pools, on-site waterfront dining, and easy access to the Historic Seaport and water activities.

Best for adults and couples who want a compact, design-forward hotel steps from Duval Street and Key West nightlife.
When The Marker Key West Harbor Resort wins: pick The Marker if you want more on-site space and facilities — a larger property with 96 rooms, three outdoor pools (including a reserved Serenity adults-only pool), a full waterfront restaurant and bar, a 24-hour fitness center, and concierge-arranged watersports. It’s the fuller-service, family-friendly option.
When The Saint Hotel Key West, Autograph Collection wins: pick The Saint for an adults-only, boutique stay within immediate reach of Duval Street, a rooftop terrace, and a compact, design-forward property if you prioritize nightlife and a smaller hotel atmosphere.
Bottom line: choose The Marker for more pools, family-friendly amenities, and larger meeting/wedding capacity; choose The Saint for a centrally located, adults-only boutique option close to Duval Street and Old Town nightlife.
| Category | The Marker Key West Harbor Resort | The Saint Hotel Key West, Autograph Collection |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Waterfront resort, resort-scale, family-friendly | Stylish adults-only boutique, compact |
| Location (Old Town) | 200 William Street — Historic Seaport waterfront, steps to the seaport | 417 Eaton Street — steps from Duval Street and Old Town nightlife |
| Size | 96 guestrooms and suites | 36 rooms |
| Ages / policy | All ages welcome; primary guest must be 21+ to check in | Adults-only property (no guests under 18) |
| Pools | Three outdoor pools (two family pools + adults-only Serenity pool); poolside bar service | One outdoor pool; rooftop terrace |
| Restaurants & bars | Starboard Restaurant & Bar (breakfast & lunch, 7:30 AM–6:00 PM) + poolside bar | Tempt (bistro with bar/lounge and pool view); limited room service hours |
| Spa & wellness | 24-hour fitness center (Peloton, Hydrow); beach and spa access at sister property Southernmost Beach Resort included via resort fee | Fitness facilities and concierge; no published standalone spa on-site |
| Known for | Waterfront location on the Historic Seaport, multiple pools, family-friendly programming | Adults-only boutique experience, proximity to Duval Street and Old Town bars/venues |
| Rooms (signature) | All rooms have private balconies and soaking tubs; 12 room types including Harbor View and Serenity Suite | 36 air-conditioned rooms (examples: Room, 1 King Bed; Loft, 1 King Bed; Sunroom Studio) |
| Walk to Duval | About three blocks from Duval Street | Steps from Duval Street (0.1 km listed) |
The Marker sits on the Key West Historic Seaport waterfront, close to marinas and seafront attractions.
Choose The Marker for a true seaport/waterfront location and easy access to boating and harbor views.
The Saint sits in Old Town just off Duval Street, focused on nightlife and short walks to bars and galleries.
Choose The Saint for being in the heart of Old Town nightlife and very near Duval Street.
The Marker’s 96 rooms emphasize private balconies and soaking tubs across a range of room types and suites.
The Marker offers broader room choices and balcony-focused rooms suited to families or longer stays.
The Saint provides a smaller selection of adult-focused rooms with boutique design touches.
The Saint is a compact option with fewer room types and an adults-only guest profile.
The Marker’s single on-site restaurant, Starboard, serves American seafood and poolside dining through the day.
Starboard and pool bars keep dining casual and focused on waterfront, daytime meals and cocktails.
The Saint’s on-site dining centers on Tempt, a bistro with a bar/lounge and pool views.
The Saint suits couples and adults who want a boutique bistro and late-afternoon/early-evening socializing near Duval.
The Marker emphasizes pool variety across its two-acre waterfront site.
If multiple pools and a mix of family/quiet options matter, The Marker is the stronger choice.
The Saint offers a compact pool and a rooftop terrace as focal points for guests.
The Saint fits travelers who prefer a smaller pool scene and rooftop social space in a boutique setting.
The Marker supports fitness and family activities plus access to sister property spa services.
Choose The Marker when fitness, family activities and arranged watersports are priorities.
The Saint is focused on adult guests and short walks to Key West nightlife.
The Saint is better when you want an adults-focused stay with immediate access to Old Town nightlife.

Three pools (including a dedicated Serenity adults-only pool), family programming and larger room options make The Marker better suited to families.

The Saint’s adults-only policy and steps-to-Duval location put you closer to bars, galleries and nightlife.

The Marker sits on the Key West Historic Seaport with waterfront dining and direct access to harbor activities.

The Saint’s smaller, design-forward property and rooftop terrace deliver a compact boutique experience.
The Marker — it welcomes children of all ages, has two family pools plus an adults-only pool, and family-oriented room configurations.
The Saint is steps from Duval Street; The Marker is a few blocks from Duval and closer to the Historic Seaport and marina.
No — neither property is an all-inclusive resort; both offer on-site restaurants and paid meals. The Marker’s resort fee covers amenities like Wi‑Fi and beach/spa access at a sister property.
No — The Saint is an adults-only property and does not permit guests under 18.
Explore how The Marker Key West Harbor Resort stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·