
The Marker Key West Harbor Resort
Best for Old Town access and a resort with multiple pools, on‑site harborfront dining, and compact waterfront grounds.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
The Marker Key West Harbor Resort is a 4‑star waterfront Old Town resort with 96 balcony rooms, three pools (including an adults‑only Serenity pool) and a harborfront restaurant — ideal for travelers who want Old Town access and multiple pool options. Margaritaville Beach House Key West is a 4‑star, island‑themed beach house resort near Smathers Beach with 186 rooms, one outdoor pool and a casual restaurant — a good pick for guests after a relaxed, beach‑facing stay and easy airport access.
Updated · about 3.1 km apart

Best for Old Town access and a resort with multiple pools, on‑site harborfront dining, and compact waterfront grounds.

Best for travelers who want a beachfront, casual island vibe close to Smathers Beach and a complimentary airport shuttle.
When The Marker Key West Harbor Resort wins: choose The Marker if you want to be in Old Town by the Historic Seaport, prefer multiple pool options (including a dedicated adults‑only Serenity pool), value a small waterfront property with balcony rooms and an on‑site harborfront restaurant (Starboard).
When Margaritaville Beach House Key West wins: choose Margaritaville if you prefer a beach‑adjacent property near Smathers Beach with a recognizable, casual tropical brand, complimentary roundtrip airport shuttle (on request), and a single‑pool, family‑friendly layout.
Bottom line: The Marker is the pick for Old Town location, more pools and intimate waterfront grounds; Margaritaville Beach House is the pick for a straightforward beach stay and easy airport access. Pick based on whether you want the harbor/Old Town scene (The Marker) or a beachside, island‑themed hotel (Margaritaville).
| Category | The Marker Key West Harbor Resort | Margaritaville Beach House Key West |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Waterfront Old Town resort, slightly boutique (96 rooms), more structured resort programming | Casual island‑themed beach house resort, larger (186 rooms), beach‑focused |
| Location | Key West Historic Seaport / Old Town waterfront, close to Duval Street and Mallory Square | By the ocean near Smathers Beach on S Roosevelt Blvd (beach access nearby) |
| Size (rooms) | 96 guestrooms and suites | 186 air‑conditioned rooms |
| Ages / family friendliness | All ages welcome; family pools plus an adults‑only Serenity pool; primary guest must be 21+ to check in | All ages welcome; family‑friendly resort (not adults‑only); primary guest age policy not published in listing |
| Pools | Three outdoor pools (two family pools + adults‑only Serenity pool) with poolside cocktail service | One outdoor pool and a hot tub; pool cabanas available (surcharge) |
| Restaurants & bars | Starboard Restaurant & Bar (waterfront, poolside) — one on‑site restaurant and a poolside bar; hours 7:30 AM–6:00 PM | One on‑site restaurant and a bar/lounge; cooked‑to‑order breakfast available for a fee (7:30 AM–11:00 AM) |
| Beach access | Not beachfront — historic seaport/harborfront location (beaches are a few kilometers away) | By the ocean and near Smathers Beach; beach access and ocean views in some rooms |
| Airport transfer | Airport shuttles and transfers can be arranged via concierge (not published as complimentary) | Roundtrip airport shuttle is complimentary (available on request) |
| Wellness & fitness | 24‑hour fitness center with Peloton and Hydrow; access included in resort fee; spa access at sister property (Southernmost Beach Resort) | 24‑hour fitness facilities listed; health/beauty spa nearby (not necessarily on site) |
| Accessibility & family services | Wheelchair‑accessible public areas and pool; family services and concierge for water activities | Wheelchair‑accessible paths and many accessible features listed; babysitting/childcare available (surcharge) |
The Marker sits on two acres beside the Key West Historic Seaport in Old Town, within easy walking distance of Duval Street and Mallory Square.
Pick The Marker for immediate access to Old Town’s harborfront, nightlife and museums.
Margaritaville Beach House Key West is positioned near Smathers Beach on South Roosevelt Boulevard for a beach‑oriented stay.
Pick Margaritaville if you want to focus on beach time and easy airport connections.
The Marker offers 96 guestrooms and suites, each with a private balcony and soaking tub.
Choose The Marker for smaller property rooms with harbor views and balcony/soaking tub amenities.
Margaritaville lists 186 air‑conditioned rooms with a mix of resort, pool and ocean views across suites and standard rooms.
Choose Margaritaville for a larger selection of suite types and direct ocean‑view room options.
The Marker’s on‑site dining centers on Starboard Restaurant & Bar, a waterfront, poolside American seafood spot.
Pick The Marker if you want a harborfront restaurant and casual poolside dining tied to Old Town views.
Margaritaville offers an on‑site restaurant and a bar/lounge with island‑themed, casual menu items.
Pick Margaritaville if you want casual, island‑themed dining with easy pool/beach transitions.
The Marker features three outdoor pools set among tropical gardens, including an adults‑only Serenity pool and poolside cocktail service.
Choose The Marker when multiple pool options and a separate adults‑only pool matter.
Margaritaville has one outdoor pool, a hot tub, and direct proximity to Smathers Beach for ocean access.
Pick Margaritaville if you prefer beach access over multiple on‑site pools.
The Marker provides a 24‑hour fitness center with Peloton and Hydrow and includes beach/spa access at Southernmost Beach Resort as part of the resort fee.
Choose The Marker for a round‑the‑clock fitness option plus arranged access to a full spa through a sister property.
Margaritaville lists 24‑hour fitness facilities and nearby health/beauty spa options, plus onsite gift shop and programmatic activities.
Pick Margaritaville if you want a basic fitness setup and to lean on nearby or on‑site casual activities and beach nightlife.

The Marker — located beside the Key West Historic Seaport and a short walk to Duval Street and Mallory Square.

Margaritaville Beach House Key West — positioned by the ocean near Smathers Beach with ocean‑view room options.

The Marker — three outdoor pools including an adults‑only Serenity pool and family pools.

Margaritaville Beach House Key West — offers complimentary roundtrip airport shuttle on request (per property listing).
The Marker — it’s on the Historic Seaport and within easy walking distance of Duval Street, Mallory Square and several museums.
Margaritaville Beach House Key West — it’s by the ocean and close to Smathers Beach, with ocean‑view rooms available.
Yes — The Marker has a dedicated adults‑only Serenity pool. Margaritaville’s listing shows one outdoor pool but not a designated adults‑only pool.
Margaritaville lists a complimentary roundtrip airport shuttle (available on request). The Marker’s concierge can arrange airport transfers but a complimentary shuttle is not published.
Explore how The Marker Key West Harbor Resort stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·