
The Marker Key West Harbor Resort
Best for staying in Old Town by the Historic Seaport with easy pedestrian access to waterfront attractions and a compact, walkable layout.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
The Marker Key West Harbor Resort is a 4-star, 96-room waterfront property in Old Town Key West with three pools and a casual waterfront restaurant; read this if you want a compact, family-friendly Harbor-area base a short walk from the Historic Seaport and Duval Street. Hilton Key West Resort & Marina is a branded 4-star marina resort with 175 rooms and multiple pools on the harbor/Stock Island side of Key West; read this if you prefer a familiar chain with on-site marina services and lots of pool options.
Updated

Best for staying in Old Town by the Historic Seaport with easy pedestrian access to waterfront attractions and a compact, walkable layout.

Best for travelers who want a larger branded marina resort with extensive on-site recreational options and multiple outdoor pools.
When The Marker wins: choose The Marker if you want to be in Old Town, steps from the Historic Seaport, Mallory Square and many waterfront bars and tours; its 96-room scale, three pools (including an adults-only Serenity Pool), and Starboard restaurant suit couples and families who plan to explore on foot.
When Hilton wins: pick the Hilton if you want a larger chain property with a marina, more outdoor pools, more on-site water-sport and boating options, and a broader array of poolside/active amenities — useful for guests who plan to spend more time on property or who value marina access.
Bottom line: both are 4-star, family-friendly harbor-area properties. The Marker is the Old Town, pedestrian-oriented choice with a compact, intimate feel and three pools; the Hilton is the bigger, marina-focused option with many pools and stronger on-site boating infrastructure.
| Category | The Marker Key West Harbor Resort | Hilton Key West Resort & Marina |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Compact Old Town waterfront resort, intimate garden-and-pool setting | Branded marina resort with larger scale and extensive on-site water recreation |
| Location | 200 William Street — beside the Key West Historic Seaport and a short walk to Duval Street and Mallory Square | 5950 Peninsular Avenue — positioned on the marina/Stock Island side of Key West with on-site marina access |
| Hotel size | 96 guestrooms and suites | 175 guestrooms |
| Star rating | 4-star | |
| Ages / family-friendliness | All ages welcome; family pools plus an adults-only Serenity Pool | |
| Pools / water access | Three outdoor pools (two family pools + adults-only Serenity Pool); poolside cocktail service | Six outdoor pools, marina and a range of on-water activities and boat tours on site |
| Restaurants & bars | Starboard Restaurant & Bar — waterfront, poolside American seafood; open daily 7:30 AM–6:00 PM plus a poolside bar | One restaurant, coffee shop/cafe, a bar/lounge and poolside bar(s); room service during limited hours |
| Fitness & wellness | 24-hour fitness center with Peloton and Hydrow; spa access available at sister property (Southernmost Beach Resort) via resort-fee | 24-hour fitness facilities on site; no specific standalone spa named in supplier listing (spa access details not published) |
| Accessibility | Accessible paths, accessible pool and accessible fitness center; elevators and accessible public areas | Wheelchair accessible parking and paths of travel; accessible rooms and features available |
| Concierge & activities | Concierge arranges snorkeling, sailing, diving, sunset excursions and ferry/tour tickets; on-site bicycle rentals | Concierge services, boat tours, bicycle rentals, water activities and multilingual staff |
The Marker sits at 200 William Street beside the Key West Historic Seaport in Old Town, within easy pedestrian reach of Duval Street and Mallory Square.
Pick The Marker to be immersed in Old Town’s historic harborfront and to walk to most attractions.
Hilton Key West Resort & Marina sits on Peninsular Avenue alongside Stock Island’s marina area and provides on-site marina facilities.
Choose the Hilton if you want a marina-side base with greater on-site boating infrastructure.
The Marker offers 96 guestrooms and suites, each with a private balcony and soaking tub as standard features.
The Marker provides consistent in-room comforts and the intimate scale of a smaller hotel.
Hilton provides 175 rooms including many partial- and full-ocean-view rooms and multiple suite configurations.
Hilton’s larger room inventory offers more view and suite choices, including many accessible configurations.
The Marker’s on-site dining is focused on Starboard Restaurant & Bar and a separate poolside bar.
The Marker keeps dining simple and focused on one main waterfront venue and nearby poolside service.
Hilton has more on-site outlets: a main restaurant, a coffee shop/cafe, and bar/lounge plus poolside bars.
Hilton gives a slightly wider set of on-site dining and beverage options, useful if you plan to eat on property more.
The Marker’s three outdoor pools are set within two acres of tropical landscaping and include an adults-only Serenity Pool.
The Marker emphasizes a garden-and-pool resort feel with a clear adults-only option.
Hilton lists six outdoor pools plus an on-site marina and a broad menu of on-water activities.
Hilton is the choice for guests who want to spend more time at pools and on boats without leaving the property.
The Marker’s 24-hour fitness center features Peloton and Hydrow equipment and the hotel is within easy walking distance of Old Town bars and nightly sunset gatherings.
The Marker suits guests who want 24-hour fitness and quick access to Old Town evenings.
Hilton offers 24-hour fitness facilities and on-site evening dining/drinking but sits on the marina side rather than in the thick of Old Town nightlife.
Hilton is better if you plan to combine fitness with on-site evening poolside or marina activities; for Old Town nightlife, expect a short trip across to the Historic Seaport area.

The Marker: steps from the Historic Seaport, Mallory Square and within walking reach of Duval Street.

Hilton: a marina on site and a wide set of boat and water-activity options available through the resort.

The Marker: three pools, one adults-only Serenity Pool and a compact guestroom count make for a quieter, garden-like resort feel.

Hilton: six outdoor pools and extensive poolside facilities give more variety for pool-focused stays.
The Marker is in Old Town beside the Historic Seaport and is the closer, more walkable option for Duval Street and Mallory Square.
Yes. Both properties accommodate families; The Marker has family pools plus an adults-only Serenity Pool, and Hilton’s policy allows children with many family-friendly room options.
Yes. Both hotels’ concierges arrange snorkeling, diving, fishing and sunset sails; Hilton also has on-site marina services and motorized watercraft options.
Hilton lists six outdoor pools; The Marker has three outdoor pools, including an adults-only Serenity Pool.
The Marker provides spa and beach access via its sister property Southernmost Beach Resort as part of the resort-fee inclusions; the supplier listing for Hilton does not publish a standalone named spa.
Explore how The Marker Key West Harbor Resort stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·