
The Marker Key West Harbor Resort
Best for easy access to the Key West Historic Seaport, multiple pools and a compact, walkable Old Town base.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
The Marker Key West Harbor Resort is a 4-star waterfront Old Town hotel with 96 balcony rooms, three pools (including an adults-only Serenity pool) and a single poolside restaurant — for travelers who want a compact, activity-friendly base by the Historic Seaport. Casa Marina Key West, Curio Collection is a historic 4-star oceanfront resort with two outdoor pools, a private beach and full-service spa — for travelers who prefer a classic, beachfront resort experience with resort-scale facilities.
Updated

Best for easy access to the Key West Historic Seaport, multiple pools and a compact, walkable Old Town base.

Best for travelers who want a historic oceanfront resort with a private beach, full spa and larger property facilities.
When The Marker wins: choose The Marker Key West Harbor Resort if you want to stay steps from the Historic Seaport and the waterfront action, prefer multiple on-site pools (including a secluded adults-only Serenity Pool), and like a compact hotel with direct concierge access to snorkeling, sailing and island tours.
When Casa Marina wins: pick Casa Marina Key West, Curio Collection if a private beach and an on-site full-service spa matter most, or if you prefer the feel of a long-established, grande-dame oceanfront property with more rooms and resort-scale public spaces.
Bottom line: both are 4-star Key West options but serve different priorities — The Marker for seaport-front, activity-oriented Old Town stays with multiple pools; Casa Marina for traditional oceanfront resort comforts and beach access.
| Category | The Marker Key West Harbor Resort | Casa Marina Key West, Curio Collection |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Contemporary waterfront boutique-resort focused on pools, harbor views and activity programming. | Historic oceanfront resort with broad lawns, private beach access and a grand-resort feel. |
| Location | Set beside the Key West Historic Seaport/Old Town waterfront (200 William Street). | Oceanfront on Reynolds Street with direct private beach access (1500 Reynolds Street). |
| Size | 96 guestrooms on a two-acre property. | 311 air-conditioned rooms and suites across a larger resort footprint. |
| Who can stay | All ages welcome; 21+ to check in (children allowed; family-friendly pools and a Serenity adults-only pool). | All ages welcome (not adults-only). |
| Pools & beach | Three outdoor pools (two family pools + adults-only Serenity pool); no private beach onsite. | Two outdoor pools and an on-site private beach. |
| Restaurants & bars | Starboard Restaurant & Bar — one main poolside waterfront restaurant and a poolside bar; casual service (7:30 AM–6:00 PM). | On-site restaurant(s) including Morrison’s Market/coffee shop and a beach bar; room service during limited hours. |
| Wellness & spa | On-site 24-hour fitness center (Peloton & Hydrow); spa access at sister property (Southernmost Beach Resort) included in resort-fee amenities. | Full-service spa on property offering massages, body treatments and facials. |
| Known for | Waterfront Old Town location beside the Historic Seaport and easy walk to Duval Street; concierge-arranged water excursions. | Historic, grande-dame oceanfront presence and private beach close to Higgs Beach and Duval Street. |
| Meeting & events | Small meeting footprint with the Garden Meeting Room (657 sq ft) plus several outdoor event options; weddings up to ~100 guests. | Significant meeting/event space (7 meeting rooms; 976 m² conference space listed). |
| Accessibility | Accessible paths, pool and fitness center; elevator and accessible public washrooms. | Wheelchair-accessible paths, pool and meeting spaces; accessible rooms and roll-in showers listed. |
The Marker sits beside the Key West Historic Seaport in Old Town, steps from waterfront dining and nearby attractions.
Choose The Marker for immediate seaport access and proximity to Old Town attractions.
Casa Marina occupies an historic oceanfront parcel with a private beach and expansive resort grounds.
Choose Casa Marina if beachfront access and a resort landscape are priorities.
The Marker has 96 guestrooms and suites, each with a private balcony and soaking tub.
The Marker suits guests who want balcony rooms with soaking tubs and harbor-facing options in a boutique-size hotel.
Casa Marina offers 311 air-conditioned rooms and suites with a broad range of ocean, pool and city views.
Casa Marina has more room variety and larger suite options, useful for guests seeking ocean views or accessible rooms.
The Marker’s dining centers on Starboard, a single waterfront restaurant and bar with poolside service.
If you want a simple, casual waterfront dining option steps from your room, The Marker covers that need.
Casa Marina lists multiple food & drink outlets including a market/coffee shop, a beach bar and limited room service.
Casa Marina provides more on-site dining variety and beachside beverage options suited to longer, lounge-y days.
Three outdoor pools set within tropical gardens, including a small adults-only Serenity pool.
The Marker is oriented toward pool variety and separate family/adult spaces.
Casa Marina offers two outdoor pools and a private stretch of beach for swimming and sunbathing.
Casa Marina is the pick for travelers prioritizing beach time with pool options as backup.
The Marker emphasizes fitness access and proximity to Old Town nightlife.
Choose The Marker if fitness and quick access to Old Town nightlife and tours are priorities.
Casa Marina focuses more on on-site relaxation with a full-service spa and quieter beachfront evenings.
Casa Marina fits travelers who want on-site spa services and lower-key, beach-oriented evenings.

The Marker — steps from the Historic Seaport, close to Mallory Square and a short walk to Duval Street.

Casa Marina — on-site private beach plus a full-service spa for true beach-resort days.

The Marker — three pools including a dedicated adults-only Serenity pool and poolside cocktail service.

Casa Marina — more rooms and larger conference/meeting space (7 meeting rooms listed).
The Marker is closer to the Historic Seaport and is within easy walking distance of Duval Street and Mallory Square.
Casa Marina Key West, Curio Collection has an on-site private beach; The Marker offers beach and spa access via its sister property as part of resort-fee inclusions.
Yes — both welcome guests of all ages. The Marker specifically notes family-friendly pools and policies for children; Casa Marina is not adults-only.
Choose Casa Marina for an on-site full-service spa. The Marker provides fitness facilities and access to a sister property’s spa as part of resort-fee benefits.
Explore how The Marker Key West Harbor Resort stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·