
The Marker Key West Harbor Resort
Best for families and Old Town access — steps from the Historic Seaport, three pools including a family pool plus an adults-only Serenity pool, and bike-friendly access to Duval Street.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
The Marker Key West Harbor Resort is a 4-star waterfront hotel in Old Town Key West with 96 rooms, three pools (including an adults-only Serenity pool) and a single on-site restaurant; read this if you want easy access to the Historic Seaport, Duval Street and family-friendly pools. The Perry Hotel & Marina Key West is a 4-star modern marina resort on Stock Island with 100 rooms, two outdoor pools, dining and on-site marina services; read this if you prefer a contemporary marina base with boating and pool amenities on Stock Island.
Updated

Best for families and Old Town access — steps from the Historic Seaport, three pools including a family pool plus an adults-only Serenity pool, and bike-friendly access to Duval Street.

Best for boaters and marina access — on-site marina and dock facilities with two pools, on-property seafood dining and easy access to Stock Island boating services.
When The Marker wins: Choose The Marker Key West Harbor Resort if you want to be in Old Town near the Historic Seaport, Mallory Square and Duval Street, if you value multiple pools (including a dedicated adults-only Serenity pool), and if you want the convenience of a single waterfront restaurant and close walking access to town attractions.
When The Perry wins: Choose The Perry Hotel & Marina Key West if you want a contemporary marina setting on Stock Island with on-site dock/marina services, two outdoor pools, a strong guest rating, and easy access to boat tours and fishing/charter departures.
Bottom line: Both are 4-star, family-friendly waterfront properties that suit different priorities — The Marker for Old Town walkability and pool variety; The Perry for marina amenities and a modern Stock Island location.
| Category | The Marker Key West Harbor Resort | The Perry Hotel & Marina Key West |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Old Town, waterfront harbor resort with gardened pool courtyards and a relaxed, family-friendly feel | Contemporary marina hotel on Stock Island with a modern, nautical focus |
| Location | 200 William Street — steps from Key West Historic Seaport and a short walk to Duval Street and Mallory Square | 7001 Shrimp Road, Stock Island — on the waterfront at a working marina |
| Size (rooms) | 96 guestrooms and suites, each with private balcony and soaking tub | 100 guestrooms and suites |
| Ages / family policy | All ages welcome; up to two children 5 and under stay free in existing bedding; 21+ to check in | All ages welcome; property is not adults-only (check-in age listed as 21+ in supplier policies) |
| Pools | Three outdoor pools (two family pools + adults-only Serenity pool); poolside bar/service | Two outdoor pools and poolside bars |
| Restaurants & bars | One main onsite restaurant and bar: Starboard (breakfast/lunch/snacks, 7:30 AM–6:00 PM) plus a poolside bar | Two restaurants on-site (includes Matt's Stock Island) plus two bars and two poolside bars |
| Spa & wellness | No standalone on-site spa; guests get beach and spa access at sister property Southernmost Beach Resort via resort-fee inclusions; 24-hour fitness center with Peloton and Hydrow | No named on-site spa listed in supplier data; 24-hour fitness facilities noted |
| Known for | Proximity to Historic Seaport, three pools including a private adults-only pool, and Starboard waterfront dining | Marina on site, dock access and boating services plus seafood dining at Matt's Stock Island |
| Parking & fees | Onsite covered self-parking available for a fee ($44/night published); daily resort fee includes WiFi and other amenities | Self-parking available onsite for a fee (supplier lists approx. $30.38/night); optional fee for cooked-to-order breakfast |
| Meeting & event space | Multiple small event spaces (Garden Meeting Room 657 sq ft, outdoor options) and wedding capacity up to 100 | Conference/meeting space about 700 sq ft and one meeting room; event services available |
| Waterfront type | Harborfront in Old Town Key West Historic Seaport | Waterfront marina setting on Stock Island with dock and boating amenities |
The Marker sits beside the Key West Historic Seaport in Old Town, steps from the seaport and an easy walk to Duval Street and Mallory Square.
Pick The Marker for immediate Old Town access and short walks to top Key West attractions.
The Perry is on Stock Island and presents a modern marina-focused location separate from Old Town.
Pick The Perry if you want on-site marina access and a Stock Island base for boating activities.
The Marker has 96 rooms and suites, each with a private balcony and soaking tub as standard.
Rooms at The Marker emphasize private balconies and soaking tubs—good for travelers who want in-room comfort and harbor views.
The Perry's room roster (about 100 rooms) offers contemporary layouts named for Perry, Mangrove, Stock Island and Lanai categories.
Choose The Perry for modern, marina-oriented rooms and a range of configurations including poolside studios and suites.
The Marker’s food and drink are centered on Starboard Restaurant & Bar — a single waterfront, poolside dining concept.
The Marker is straightforward: one main restaurant and poolside bar focused on casual waterfront fare.
The Perry lists two on-site dining options (including Matt’s Stock Island) and multiple bars for guests.
The Perry offers more on-site dining variety and a notable seafood restaurant, useful for guests who want marina-side dining options.
The Marker offers three outdoor pools set in two acres of tropical gardens, including an adults-only Serenity pool.
Bring the family or seek a quieter pool — The Marker covers both with family pools plus an adults-only option.
The Perry provides two outdoor pools and full marina/dock facilities for boating guests.
The Perry is geared to guests who plan to use marina services and want straightforward poolside social spaces.
The Marker includes a 24-hour fitness center with Peloton and Hydrow, and spa access at its sister property via resort fee.
The Marker covers fitness needs directly and provides spa access through a sister property, plus easy evenings in Old Town.
The Perry includes a 24-hour fitness facility and positions itself as a marina hub where nightlife and dining are concentrated on- and off-property.
The Perry provides fitness and on-site evening dining/drink options; seek downtown Key West for broader nightlife.

The Marker — steps from the Historic Seaport, within easy walking distance of Duval Street, Mallory Square and Old Town attractions.

The Perry — on-site marina, dock and boat services plus fish-cleaning facilities make it better suited for boating-focused trips.

The Marker — three distinct outdoor pools, including a dedicated adults-only Serenity pool and family pools.

The Perry — supplier listing shows two restaurants and multiple bars, including Matt’s Stock Island, for more on-site dining choices.
The Marker is located in Old Town beside the Historic Seaport and is a short walk to Duval Street and Mallory Square; The Perry is on Stock Island, separate from Old Town.
The Perry is better for boaters — it lists an on-site marina, dock and boating services. The Marker is waterfront at the Historic Seaport but does not list on-site marina/dock services.
No — both are family-friendly and accept guests of all ages; neither is listed as adults-only.
The Marker does not have a standalone on-site spa but includes access to the spa at Southernmost Beach Resort via the resort fee. The Perry’s supplier data does not publish a named on-site spa.
Explore how The Marker Key West Harbor Resort stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·