
The Marker Key West Harbor Resort
Best for families and waterfront Old Town access — three pools, on-site kids/family-friendly spaces and a harborfront location close to Duval Street and Mallory Square.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
The Marker Key West Harbor Resort is a 4-star waterfront resort in Old Town Key West with 96 rooms, three pools (including an adults-only Serenity pool) and a casual waterfront restaurant — read this if you want easy access to the Historic Seaport, Mallory Square and family-friendly pool options. The Gates Hotel Key West is a 4-star contemporary, New Town property with about 100 rooms and a focus on accessible amenities — read this if you want a modern hotel with good name recognition outside Old Town and easy access to airport-area attractions.
Updated · about 3.5 miles apart

Best for families and waterfront Old Town access — three pools, on-site kids/family-friendly spaces and a harborfront location close to Duval Street and Mallory Square.

Best for travelers who want a contemporary, accessible hotel in New Town with straightforward on-site amenities and shuttle/parking options.
When The Marker Key West Harbor Resort wins: choose The Marker if you want to stay inside Old Town near the Historic Seaport, want a true waterfront setting and prefer multiple pools (including separate family pools plus an adults-only Serenity pool) plus on-site waterfront dining.
When The Gates Hotel Key West wins: pick The Gates if you prioritize a modern, widely marketed New Town hotel with broad accessibility features, straightforward parking and shuttle options, and proximity to Key West International Airport and New Town attractions.
Bottom line: The Marker is the better fit for travelers who want Old Town convenience, harbor views and more pool options; The Gates is a practical pick for guests seeking a contemporary, accessible property in New Town and closer to the airport.
| Category | The Marker Key West Harbor Resort | The Gates Hotel Key West |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Waterfront Old Town resort with a casual, family-friendly tone | Contemporary lifestyle hotel at the entrance to Key West (New Town) |
| Location | Key West Historic Seaport / Old Town — walkable to Duval Street and Mallory Square | New Town (near Roosevelt Blvd) — closer to Key West Intl. Airport and New Town attractions |
| Size | 96 guestrooms and suites | About 100 air-conditioned rooms |
| Ages / audience | All ages welcome; must be 21+ to check in; family- and kid-friendly | All ages welcome; property is not adults-only |
| Pools | Three outdoor pools (two family pools + adults-only Serenity pool); poolside bar/service | One outdoor pool listed; poolside bar/lounges available |
| Restaurants & bars | Starboard Restaurant & Bar (waterfront, poolside; breakfast & lunch hours listed) + poolside bar | Two restaurants and a bar/lounge plus a coffee shop/cafe; poolside bar mentioned |
| Spa & fitness | 24-hour fitness center with Peloton and Hydrow; beach and spa access at Southernmost Beach Resort (sister property) | Fitness facilities listed; 'health or beauty spa nearby' (no named on-site spa published) |
| Known for | Harborfront location, multiple pools, Starboard waterfront dining and wedding/event venues | Accessible features and modern New Town location with shuttle/parking options |
| Parking & transport | Onsite covered self-parking (fee) and bike rentals; walkable to many Old Town sites | Uncovered self parking (surcharge), long-term parking (surcharge) and airport proximity; area shuttle (surcharge) |
| Accessibility | Accessible public washrooms, pool access and accessible fitness center | Extensive accessibility features listed (ramps, braille/raised signage, accessible registration and dining) |
The Marker sits beside the Key West Historic Seaport and is a short walk to Duval Street and Mallory Square.
Best if you want Old Town access and quick walks to the island’s historic waterfront attractions.
The Gates is positioned at the entrance to Key West in New Town, closer to airport-area roads and services.
Best if you prefer a New Town base near the airport and straightforward vehicle access.
The Marker offers 96 rooms and suites, each with a private balcony and soaking tub.
Choose The Marker for balcony rooms and in-room soaking tubs with harbor or garden views.
The Gates lists roughly 100 air-conditioned rooms with standard modern amenities.
Choose The Gates if you want a modern, accessibility-focused room inventory in New Town.
The Marker’s dining centers on Starboard, a waterfront restaurant and bar open for breakfast and lunch with poolside service.
If you want one reliable waterfront dining spot open daytime hours, The Marker’s Starboard covers it.
The Gates lists two restaurants, a bar/lounge and a coffee shop/cafe across the property.
The Gates gives a bit more variety on site across multiple outlets, including a café option.
The Marker has three outdoor pools set within two acres of tropical gardens and poolside cocktail service.
The Marker is stronger for guests who prioritize multiple pool choices and poolside service.
The Gates has one outdoor pool listed and offers access to nearby pools/spa options through local providers.
The Gates suits travelers who want a single, modern pool and easy access to New Town leisure options.
The Marker includes a 24-hour fitness center with Peloton and Hydrow and provides beach & spa access at a sister property.
The Marker is a fit if you want strong fitness options on site plus sister-property spa access and Old Town evening life nearby.
The Gates provides fitness facilities on site and listings for nearby health/beauty spa services.
The Gates suits travelers who want basic on-site fitness and to arrange local spa or activity services through the hotel.

Waterfront location beside the Historic Seaport, easy walking access to Duval Street and Mallory Square.

Three pools including two family pools plus a private Serenity adults-only pool.

Extensive published accessibility features (ramps, braille signage, accessible registration and dining).

New Town location with closer proximity to Key West International Airport and parking/shuttle options.
The Marker — it explicitly markets family-friendly pools (two family pools), welcomes children of all ages and is steps from Old Town attractions.
The Gates is in New Town and is closer to the airport; The Marker is in Old Town nearer to the Historic Seaport.
The Marker does not have a named on-site spa but includes beach and spa access at Southernmost Beach Resort; The Gates lists a health/beauty spa 'nearby' but no named on-site spa is published.
Yes. Both properties publish accessible features for rooms, public areas and pools; The Gates highlights extensive accessibility accommodations.
Explore how The Marker Key West Harbor Resort stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·