
The Marker Key West Harbor Resort
Best for families and guests who want a larger waterfront resort with multiple pools, a fitness center, and an on-site restaurant.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
The Marker Key West Harbor Resort is a 4-star, 96-room waterfront resort at the Historic Seaport with three pools and one on-site restaurant — good for families and travelers who want resort facilities near Duval Street. Orchid Key Inn is a 3.5-star, adults-only boutique inn on Duval Street with 24 individually furnished rooms and a small outdoor pool — aimed at adults and couples who prioritize location and personalized service.
Updated · about 0.4 km apart

Best for families and guests who want a larger waterfront resort with multiple pools, a fitness center, and an on-site restaurant.

Best for adults and couples who want an intimate, centrally located boutique stay steps from Duval Street and nearby attractions.
When The Marker wins: choose The Marker Key West Harbor Resort if you want a full-service waterfront property with multiple pools (including a dedicated adults-only Serenity pool), a 24-hour fitness center, concierge-arranged watersports and an onsite waterfront restaurant. It’s the more resort-style, family-friendly option.
When Orchid Key Inn wins: choose Orchid Key Inn if you want an adults-only, small-property experience right on Duval Street, with individually styled rooms, a single outdoor pool and a continental breakfast included — ideal for couples focused on location and low-key service.
Bottom line: pick The Marker for resort amenities, waterfront setting and family flexibility; pick Orchid Key Inn for a compact, adults-only Duval Street base. Both are in Old Town Key West and put you within easy walking distance of bars, museums and the seaport.
| Category | The Marker Key West Harbor Resort | Orchid Key Inn |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Resort-style waterfront property with tropical gardens and multiple pools | Small adults-only boutique inn with an intimate feel |
| Location | Key West Historic Seaport / waterfront, a few blocks from Duval Street | On Duval Street, steps from restaurants, bars and Hemingway sites |
| Size | 96 guestrooms and suites | 24 individually furnished guestrooms |
| Ages | All ages welcome (primary guest must be 21+ to check in) | Adults-only (guests must be 18+ per property policy) |
| Pools | Three outdoor pools, including a dedicated adults-only 'Serenity' pool; poolside bar service | One outdoor pool and one hot tub; poolside bar/lounge service available |
| Restaurants & bars | Starboard Restaurant & Bar (waterfront, open daily 7:30 AM–6:00 PM) + poolside bar | Bar/lounge and poolside bar; complimentary continental breakfast served daily |
| Spa & wellness | No standalone on-site spa; guests receive beach and spa access at sister property Southernmost Beach Resort via resort-fee inclusions; 24-hour fitness center with Peloton/Hydrow | Not published |
| Known for | Waterfront location at the Historic Seaport, multiple pools and larger event spaces | Adults-only, Duval Street proximity and highly rated boutique service |
| Accessibility | Elevator and accessible public areas; accessible pool | Wheelchair-accessible features listed (rooms and public areas); no elevator (single-level property) |
| Parking | Onsite covered self-parking for a fee (published by property) | Self parking available onsite for a fee (in/out privileges) per supplier listing |
The Marker sits beside the Key West Historic Seaport on William Street, a short walk to Old Town attractions and the seaport docks.
Choose The Marker for a true harborfront base with easy access to seaport activities.
Orchid Key Inn is located at 1004 Duval Street, essentially on Duval and within steps of many bars, museums and the Ernest Hemingway Home.
Choose Orchid Key Inn if you want to be in the middle of Duval Street’s restaurants and nightlife.
The Marker has 96 rooms and suites, each with a private balcony and soaking tub; several room categories look over the pool, garden or harbor.
The Marker offers more room choices and larger inventory for groups and families.
Orchid Key Inn has 24 individually furnished guestrooms, including Deluxe and Suite options.
Orchid Key Inn provides intimate, boutique-style rooms with in-room conveniences for adults and couples.
The Marker’s single on-site restaurant, Starboard, is a waterfront, poolside spot serving breakfast and lunch with a casual dress code.
The Marker provides full poolside and waterfront dining through Starboard and bar service.
Orchid Key Inn offers a bar/lounge and poolside bar service; a complimentary continental breakfast is served daily.
Orchid Key Inn focuses on simple, included breakfast and nearby dining options on Duval Street.
The Marker’s standout amenity is its three outdoor pools set within two acres of tropical gardens, including a tucked-away adults-only Serenity pool.
The Marker is the place for guests who want multiple pool options and poolside service.
Orchid Key Inn has a single outdoor pool and one hot tub for guests to relax beside.
Orchid Key Inn works well for quieter pool time but does not offer multiple pool choices.
The Marker provides a 24-hour fitness center and easy access to seaport evening activities and nearby nightlife on Duval Street.
The Marker blends a full fitness offering with easy access to Key West’s evening scene.
Orchid Key Inn’s location on Duval Street puts guests steps from the island’s bars and evening attractions, while the property itself stays low-key.
Orchid Key Inn is best for guests who plan to spend evenings on Duval and want an adults-only base.

The Marker — multiple pools (including family pools), more rooms, and family-friendly policies with kids welcome.

Orchid Key Inn — adults-only policy, intimate scale and steps from Duval Street’s nightlife and attractions.

The Marker — waterfront Starboard restaurant, poolside bar service, three pools and a 24-hour fitness center.

Orchid Key Inn — located directly on Duval Street for easy access to bars, museums and the Hemingway Home.
Orchid Key Inn — it is located at 1004 Duval Street and puts you steps from Duval’s restaurants and nightlife.
The Marker — children of all ages are welcome, and the resort has two family pools in addition to an adults-only pool.
The Marker does not list a standalone on-site spa; resort-fee inclusions give guests access to the beach and spa facilities at its sister property, Southernmost Beach Resort.
Yes — Orchid Key Inn is adults-only and typically attracts couples and adults looking for a smaller boutique property near Duval Street.
Explore how The Marker Key West Harbor Resort stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·