
The Marker Key West Harbor Resort
Best for families and active travelers who want multiple pools, a fitness center with Peloton/Hydrow, and a seaport/Old Town location.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
The Marker Key West Harbor Resort is a 4-star, 96-room waterfront resort in Old Town Key West with three outdoor pools, a waterfront restaurant (Starboard) and a 24-hour fitness center; read this if you want a family-friendly, seaport-side base with multiple pools and organized concierge activity options. Southernmost Beach Resort & Guesthouses is a large beachfront resort near the Southernmost Point area, with direct beach access, outdoor pool(s) and broad on-site services; read this if you prioritize beach access and a resort with many room-type options near the southern tip of Key West.
Updated · about 2.0 km apart

Best for families and active travelers who want multiple pools, a fitness center with Peloton/Hydrow, and a seaport/Old Town location.

Best for guests who want direct beach access and a larger beachfront resort footprint with many room configurations.
When The Marker Key West Harbor Resort wins: Choose The Marker if you want a compact, upscale Old Town waterfront stay with multiple pools (including a dedicated adults-only Serenity pool), an on-site waterfront restaurant (Starboard), and a 24-hour fitness center with Peloton and Hydrow equipment. It’s the stronger choice for families who want varied pool options and proximity to the Historic Seaport and Mallory Square events.
When Southernmost Beach Resort & Guesthouses wins: Choose Southernmost Beach Resort if your priority is direct beach access and a larger beachfront property with a broad mix of room types — it’s the better pick for travelers who put the beach first or need specific room configurations. The property emphasizes beach and spa services and has convenient concierge and tour support.
Bottom line: Both are 4-star Key West options but serve slightly different needs: The Marker is a seaport-side, pool-forward hotel with strong fitness and family features; Southernmost Beach Resort & Guesthouses is the go-to if being on the sand and having many room-type choices matters more than a seaport address.
| Category | The Marker Key West Harbor Resort | Southernmost Beach Resort & Guesthouses |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Seaport-side, resort with gardens and three pools; active/convenient for Old Town activities | Large beachfront resort near Southernmost Point, resort-style with beach access and broad services |
| Location | 200 William Street — Key West Historic Seaport / Old Town | 1319 Duval Street — Southernmost Point area, beachfront |
| Size (rooms) | 96 guestrooms and suites | Not published |
| Ages / audience | All ages welcome (must be 21+ to check in); family-friendly with an adults-only pool | All ages welcome (property not adults-only) with some adults-only room offerings listed |
| Pools / beach | Three outdoor pools, including an adults-only 'Serenity' pool and two family pools | Swimming pool [outdoor]; beachfront access available |
| Restaurants & bars | Starboard Restaurant & Bar (waterfront, 7:30 AM–6:00 PM) plus poolside bar | On-site restaurants and bar(s) listed; multiple meal options available |
| Spa & wellness | 24-hour fitness center (Peloton & Hydrow); spa and beach access included via sister-property arrangement | Spa services and massage listed on property amenities |
| Known for | Waterfront Old Town location, three pools, strong fitness offering and concierge-arranged water activities | Beach access near Southernmost Point and broad guest services (tours, concierge, dining) |
| Check-in / check-out | Check-in 4:00 PM (late until midnight subject to availability); check-out before 11:00 AM | Check-in begins 4:00 PM; check-out time: 2:00 AM (supplier listing) |
| Accessibility & services | Accessible pools, accessible fitness center, complimentary Wi‑Fi, bike rentals, covered parking (fee) | Wheelchair accessible, complimentary Wi‑Fi, concierge, car park (charges may apply) |
The Marker sits at 200 William Street beside the Key West Historic Seaport and Old Town waterfront.
Choose The Marker for a seaport/Old Town waterfront address and easy access to Old Town attractions.
Southernmost Beach Resort & Guesthouses is positioned near the Southernmost Point area with direct beach access.
Choose Southernmost Beach Resort when you want to be close to the Southernmost Point and on or very near the beach.
The Marker has 96 guestrooms and suites, all with private balconies and soaking tubs.
The Marker’s consistent room inventory (balconies and soaking tubs across rooms) suits travelers who want predictable, upgraded in-room touches.
Southernmost Beach Resort & Guesthouses lists many room-name variants covering economy, deluxe, pool and ocean views.
Southernmost’s long room list makes it a practical pick if you need a specific bed configuration or want ocean/partial-ocean options.
The Marker’s on-site dining centers on Starboard Restaurant & Bar and a separate poolside bar.
The Marker keeps food and drink casual and waterfront-focused with one main restaurant and poolside beverage service.
Southernmost Beach Resort & Guesthouses lists multiple on-site restaurants and bar services among its amenities.
Southernmost provides full-service dining and bar options appropriate for guests who want to eat on-site after beach time.
The Marker features three outdoor pools set in tropical gardens, with poolside cocktail service and an adults-only Serenity pool.
Pick The Marker if you want multiple kinds of pool experiences (family and adults-only) in an Old Town setting.
Southernmost Beach Resort & Guesthouses offers outdoor pool(s) and direct beach access for guests.
Pick Southernmost Beach Resort if immediate beach access is your priority — pools are available, but the defining feature is the beachfront location.
The Marker emphasizes fitness-plus-relaxation with a 24-hour fitness center and arranged beach/spa access.
The Marker is a strong option for fitness-minded travelers who still want easy evening access to Old Town nightlife and waterfront sunset activities.
Southernmost Beach Resort & Guesthouses lists massage and spa services plus daily activities.
Southernmost is best when you want beach-and-spa downtime with easy evenings on or near Duval Street.

Three pools (two family pools plus a Serenity adults-only pool), family-friendly room options, and a seaport/Old Town location near attractions.

Direct beach access and beachfront positioning near the Southernmost Point make it the stronger pick for people who want sand-first days.

A 24-hour fitness center with Peloton and Hydrow equipment included in resort amenities supports serious workouts any time.

A long list of named room types (from economy doubles to three-bedroom residences and ocean-view rooms) gives more options for specific bed counts and layouts.
The Marker Key West Harbor Resort is located beside the Key West Historic Seaport and is within easy walking distance of Mallory Square; Southernmost Beach Resort is farther south near the Southernmost Point.
Southernmost Beach Resort & Guesthouses provides beachfront access; The Marker provides beach and spa access through a sister-property arrangement included in its resort-fee amenities.
Yes — both welcome guests of all ages. The Marker highlights family-friendly pools plus an adults-only Serenity pool, while Southernmost lists a range of room types and on-site services suitable for families.
The Marker’s on-site restaurant is Starboard Restaurant & Bar (waterfront, 7:30 AM–6:00 PM). Southernmost Beach Resort & Guesthouses lists multiple restaurants and a bar among its amenities.
Explore how The Marker Key West Harbor Resort stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·