
The Marker Key West Harbor Resort
Best for travelers who want Old Town/Harborfront access, short walks to Duval Street and a compact resort with three pools and a single onsite restaurant.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
The Marker Key West Harbor Resort is a 4-star, 96-room waterfront Old Town resort beside the Key West Historic Seaport; read this if you want an in-town harborfront base with multiple pools and quick walking access to Duval Street and Mallory Square. Parrot Key Hotel & Villas is a 4-star, larger tropical resort-style property on Key West’s north side with villas, multiple pools and a quieter, garden-forward feel—read this if you want a lush resort layout and villa options away from Old Town’s busiest blocks.
Updated

Best for travelers who want Old Town/Harborfront access, short walks to Duval Street and a compact resort with three pools and a single onsite restaurant.

Best for guests seeking a resort-within-Key-West that feels set apart from the busiest tourist strip, with villa-style rooms and multiple pool options.
When The Marker wins: Choose The Marker if you want to be steps from the Key West Historic Seaport and within easy walking reach of Duval Street, prefer a smaller waterfront property with three pools (including a private Serenity adults-only pool), and value a single convenient onsite restaurant and 24-hour fitness center.
When Parrot Key wins: Choose Parrot Key Hotel & Villas if you want resort-style grounds, villa layouts or larger suites, more outdoor pool options across a bigger property, and a quieter setting away from the busiest parts of Old Town.
Bottom line: Both are 4-star Key West options with pool-forward offerings. Pick The Marker for Old Town, harborfront convenience and a compact property; pick Parrot Key for a resort-style villa experience and more pool variety.
| Category | The Marker Key West Harbor Resort | Parrot Key Hotel & Villas |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Compact harborfront Old Town resort with a focus on waterfront dining and three pools. | Tropical resort-style property with villas, garden areas and multiple outdoor pools. |
| Location | 200 William Street — in the Key West Historic Seaport / Old Town waterfront. | 2801 N Roosevelt Blvd — Northside Resort area of Key West (quieter, away from central Duval). |
| Size (rooms) | 96 guestrooms and suites. | 148 individually decorated guestrooms and villas (listing). |
| Audience / ages | All ages welcome; one pool is adults-only (Serenity Pool). | All ages welcome (not adults-only). |
| Pools | Three outdoor pools: two family pools + one adults-only Serenity pool; wheelchair-accessible pools. | Four outdoor pools and poolside bar; resort-style spread across grounds. |
| Restaurants & bars | Starboard Restaurant & Bar — one onsite restaurant and a separate poolside bar; open daily 7:30 AM–6:00 PM. | The Grove Food Truck (onsite restaurant), plus a bar and poolside bar; room service (limited hours). |
| Spa & wellness | 24-hour fitness center with Peloton & Hydrow; beach and spa access at sister property Southernmost Beach Resort (via resort fee). | Fitness facilities listed; a standalone onsite spa name is not published. |
| Known for | Waterfront location in Old Town, private balconies and soaking tubs in every room, and easy access to harbor activities. | Lush, resort-style layout with villas and multiple pools; complimentary beach shuttle and marina access nearby. |
| Transport & access | Walking distance to Key West Historic Seaport, Duval Street and local attractions; on-site covered self-parking (fee). | Free area shuttle and free beach shuttle; valet parking available for a surcharge and an on-site marina nearby. |
| Pet policy | Dogs allowed (fee applies; documented pet fees and limits). | Pets allowed in specific rooms only (restrictions and surcharges apply). |
The Marker sits on two acres beside the Key West Historic Seaport in Old Town, steps from harborfront attractions and a short walk to Duval Street.
Choose The Marker for immediate Old Town/harborfront access and walkability to Key West’s main attractions.
Parrot Key is located on Key West’s north side (Northside Resort area), offering a quieter base with resort-style grounds.
Pick Parrot Key when you want resort seclusion and grounds separate from Old Town’s busiest blocks.
The Marker has 96 guestrooms and suites; every room includes a private balcony and a soaking tub.
The Marker is a smaller, consistent inventory with balcony & soaking-tub features in every room.
Parrot Key offers a wide mix of guest rooms, suites and multi-bedroom villas across a larger property.
Parrot Key is the better choice for families or groups who want villa and multi-bedroom suite options.
The Marker’s single main dining outlet is Starboard, a waterfront American seafood restaurant with poolside seating.
If you want one reliable waterfront restaurant and poolside service steps from your room, The Marker delivers it in Old Town.
Parrot Key’s on-site dining includes The Grove Food Truck and bar/pool service; room service is available during limited hours.
Parrot Key offers casual onsite options and poolside drinks, but fewer full-service restaurant hours compared with a central Old Town location.
The Marker’s defining amenity is its three outdoor pools set among two acres of tropical gardens, including a tucked-away adults-only Serenity Pool.
The Marker is ideal if you want a small-property pool complex combined with Old Town and harbor access.
Parrot Key emphasizes resort-style grounds with multiple pools—four outdoor pools are listed for guests.
Parrot Key suits travelers who prioritize a wider variety of pool areas and a more spread-out resort feel.
The Marker has a 24-hour fitness center with Peloton and Hydrow gear and easy access to Old Town evening activities.
Choose The Marker if you want gym access plus immediate access to Old Town’s nighttime options.
Parrot Key lists fitness facilities and favors quieter evenings on property; nightlife is typically a short ride away into town.
Parrot Key is better for low-key evenings on property and for guests willing to travel into Old Town for heavier nightlife.

The Marker — steps from the Key West Historic Seaport, easy walking access to Duval Street and waterfront dining.

Parrot Key — wide mix of one-, two- and three-bedroom villas and larger suites for families and groups.

The Marker — 24-hour fitness center with Peloton and Hydrow and a compact layout with consistent room features.

Parrot Key — four outdoor pools and a gardened, resort-style property feel.
The Marker is in Old Town and within easy walking distance of Duval Street and Mallory Square; Parrot Key is on the north side and requires a longer trip into central Old Town.
Both welcome children of all ages, but Parrot Key’s villa and multi-bedroom options suit larger families; The Marker has family pools plus an adults-only pool and is more walkable to family-friendly Old Town attractions.
The Marker offers beach and spa access at its sister property, Southernmost Beach Resort (via the resort-fee inclusions). A named onsite spa at Parrot Key is not published.
No. Both properties welcome guests of all ages; The Marker does operate a dedicated adults-only Serenity Pool on property.
The Marker has one main restaurant (Starboard) plus poolside bar service; Parrot Key has The Grove Food Truck, a bar and poolside service—both properties are better for casual onsite dining than for multiple full-service restaurants.
Explore how The Marker Key West Harbor Resort stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·