
The Marker Key West Harbor Resort
Best for families and groups who want multiple pools, on-site dining and a seaport location.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
The Marker Key West Harbor Resort is a 4-star, family-friendly waterfront resort with 96 rooms, three pools, and an on-site waterfront restaurant — good for families and activity-minded travelers. The Gardens Hotel is an elegant, highly rated 4-star boutique property set in lush gardens and limited to adults — a better fit for couples and travelers seeking a quieter, romantic stay.
Updated · about 0.8 km apart

Best for families and groups who want multiple pools, on-site dining and a seaport location.

Best for couples or adults wanting a small, quiet, garden-focused boutique stay close to Duval Street.
When The Marker Key West Harbor Resort wins: choose The Marker if you want a larger resort with multiple pools (including a dedicated adults-only Serenity pool), an on-site waterfront restaurant and easy access to the Historic Seaport and water-based excursions. It’s the more family- and activity-friendly pick.
When The Gardens Hotel wins: pick The Gardens if you want an intimate, high-rated adults-only boutique hotel set in gardens, with a strong reputation for service and a very central Old Town location steps from Duval Street.
Bottom line: The Marker is the practical choice for families or groups who want resort amenities and a harborfront location; The Gardens is the choice for adult travelers or couples prioritizing a quiet, garden boutique experience and very high guest ratings.
| Category | The Marker Key West Harbor Resort | The Gardens Hotel |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Waterfront, resort-style with tropical gardens and three pools | Elegant boutique hotel in a lush, garden setting |
| Location | Key West Historic Seaport / waterfront at 200 William Street (Old Town) | Central Old Town location at 526 Angela Street, steps from Duval Street |
| Size (rooms) | 96 guestrooms and suites | 21 rooms |
| Ages / guest policy | All ages welcome; primary guest must be 21+ to check in | Adults-only (guests under 16 not permitted) |
| Pools | Three outdoor pools (two family pools + adults-only Serenity pool) | Two outdoor pools |
| Restaurants & bars | One main restaurant & bar (Starboard) plus a poolside bar | One restaurant and 2 bars/lounges listed |
| Spa & wellness | 24-hour fitness center onsite; beach and spa access available at sister property Southernmost Beach Resort | Health/beauty spa nearby (no named full-service spa published onsite) |
| Known for | Waterfront seaport location, three pools, family amenities and concierge-arranged water excursions | High guest rating, peaceful garden grounds, central Old Town walkability |
| Parking & pets | Covered self-parking available (fee); dogs allowed with fee | Self parking (surcharge); pets allowed in specific rooms (fee) |
The Marker sits beside the Key West Historic Seaport on two acres at 200 William Street, steps from the harbor and within easy walk of Old Town attractions.
Choose The Marker for direct seaport access and quick water-activity pick-up points.
The Gardens Hotel is centrally located in Old Town Key West at 526 Angela Street, very near Duval Street and main attractions.
Choose The Gardens for immediate Old Town walkability and a quieter street-side location.
The Marker offers 96 guestrooms and suites, all with private balconies and soaking tubs as standard features.
The Marker delivers consistent in-room features across a larger inventory — good when you need availability and variety.
The Gardens Hotel is a small boutique property with 21 air-conditioned rooms and a selection of cottage and suite types.
The Gardens suits travelers who prefer a small property and individually styled rooms over a larger resort inventory.
The Marker’s on-site dining focal point is Starboard Restaurant & Bar, a waterfront, poolside venue serving breakfast, lunch and snacks.
The Marker provides simple, casual waterfront dining geared to families and resort guests.
The Gardens Hotel lists an on-site restaurant and two bars/lounges and emphasizes a relaxed, intimate dining experience.
The Gardens focuses on a quieter, boutique dining rhythm with breakfast included and lounge options for adults.
The Marker features three outdoor pools across two acres, including a private adults-only Serenity pool and poolside cocktail service.
The Marker offers more pool options for mixed-age travel parties, including a dedicated adults-only pool.
The Gardens Hotel operates two outdoor pools set within its garden grounds as central quiet features of the property.
The Gardens is a better pick if you want a quieter pool experience in a small, garden-focused setting.
The Marker provides a 24-hour fitness center plus arranged access to a sister property's beach and spa.
The Marker suits travelers who want on-site fitness and easy access to organized excursions and evening seaport activity.
The Gardens lists wellness-adjacent features and is quieter at night; a named on-site spa is not published.
The Gardens works for travelers who want a peaceful, low-key evening at the hotel with easy access to Old Town nightlife.

Three pools (including a family-friendly kids area), larger room inventory and activity-friendly seaport location make The Marker the practical family pick.

The Gardens Hotel is adults-only with small property scale and garden grounds — better for couples seeking quiet and privacy.

The Marker’s location beside the Historic Seaport and concierge services for diving, snorkeling and ferry departures make booking water trips easy.

With a guest rating of 9.8 and boutique scale, The Gardens is ideal if service and an intimate setting are a priority.
The Marker — it welcomes children of all ages, has two family pools plus a separate kids/family-friendly pool, and a larger room inventory.
The Gardens Hotel — it is adults-only, smaller and emphasizes quiet garden grounds and an intimate atmosphere.
The Marker does not list a named on-site spa but includes access to the beach and spa at Southernmost Beach Resort; The Gardens lists a health/beauty spa nearby rather than a named on-site spa.
The Gardens Hotel is steps from Duval Street; The Marker is also walkable to Duval but is positioned at the Historic Seaport.
Explore how The Marker Key West Harbor Resort stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·