
The Marker Key West Harbor Resort
Best for families and travelers who want a full-service waterfront resort with multiple pools, a fitness center and on-site dining.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
The Marker Key West Harbor Resort is a 4-star waterfront resort in the Old Town Historic Seaport with 96 rooms, three pools (including an adults-only Serenity pool) and an on-site American seafood restaurant, Starboard. Eden House is a long-running 4-star boutique inn in Old Town known for its relaxed, locally focused atmosphere and a single outdoor pool — read this if you want a comparison between a full-service waterfront resort and a smaller, character-driven inn.
Updated · about 0.8 km apart

Best for families and travelers who want a full-service waterfront resort with multiple pools, a fitness center and on-site dining.

Best for travelers who prefer a smaller, locally run inn with individually decorated rooms and a quieter, intimate Old Town experience.
When The Marker Key West Harbor Resort wins: Choose The Marker if you want more on-site facilities (three pools including a separate adults-only pool, a 24-hour fitness center with Peloton and Hydrow, and a larger waterfront restaurant) and a property positioned directly beside the Key West Historic Seaport.
When Eden House wins: Choose Eden House if you value a long-running boutique inn vibe, individually decorated guestrooms, a compact garden-and-pool setting, and a hotel popular with repeat guests who want a low-key Old Town stay.
Bottom line: The Marker is the better pick for families and guests who want resort amenities and easy access to harborfront activity; Eden House suits travelers after a smaller, characterful inn and a quieter, more intimate Old Town base.
| Category | The Marker Key West Harbor Resort | Eden House |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Waterfront resort, contemporary 4-star property with resort facilities | Long-running tropical boutique inn with individually decorated rooms |
| Location (Old Town / Seaport) | Beside the Key West Historic Seaport, three blocks from Duval Street | |
| Size (rooms) | 96 guestrooms and suites | 39 individually decorated guestrooms |
| Ages / family-friendliness | All ages welcome; family pools plus adults-only Serenity pool; 21+ to check in | All ages welcome (not adults-only); not positioned as a family resort |
| Pools & pool scene | Three outdoor pools (two family pools + adults-only Serenity pool); poolside bar service | One outdoor pool and a hot tub in a garden setting |
| Restaurants & bars | Starboard Restaurant & Bar (waterfront poolside American seafood; open 7:30 AM–6:00 PM) + poolside bar | Azur (Mediterranean) plus a coffee shop/cafe and a poolside bar |
| Spa & wellness | 24-hour fitness center on-site (Peloton & Hydrow); access to beach/spa at sister Southernmost Beach Resort included in resort fee | Health or beauty spa nearby is listed on supplier listing; no named on-site spa published |
| Known for | Waterfront location beside the Historic Seaport, multiple pools and family-friendly facilities | Locally focused boutique character and loyal repeat guests |
| Airport distance (EYW) | Nearest airport ~2.5 miles / roughly 10–15 min from the resort (Key West Intl., EYW) per published sources | Preferred airport listed as Key West Intl. Airport (EYW) ~5.5 km / 3.4 mi from Eden House (supplier listing) |
| On-site meeting / event space | Multiple event venues including Garden Meeting Room (655 sq ft) and poolside/event gardens; wedding capacity up to ~100 | Wedding services available; small boutique event capability |
The Marker sits beside the Key West Historic Seaport and places you steps from harborfront activity and a short walk to Duval Street.
Pick The Marker if you want direct seaport access and immediate waterfront activity.
Eden House is a long-running boutique inn in Old Town that sits within easy walking distance of Duval Street and several small beaches.
Pick Eden House if you prefer a quieter, more residential Old Town base a short walk from main sights.
The Marker has 96 guestrooms and suites, each with a private balcony and soaking tub, and multiple room types including harbor-view suites.
Choose The Marker for a larger selection of suite types and consistent modern resort rooms.
Eden House offers 39 individually decorated guestrooms ranging from island rooms to suites.
Choose Eden House for a boutique, individually styled room experience.
The Marker’s sole on-site restaurant is Starboard, a waterfront poolside spot serving breakfast, lunch, seafood and cocktails.
Roster your meals at The Marker for straightforward waterfront breakfasts and lunches without leaving the property.
Eden House lists Azur as its Mediterranean on-site restaurant plus a coffee shop/cafe for lighter fare.
Eden House is better for quieter, locally flavored dining and a more intimate evening atmosphere.
The Marker has three outdoor pools set within two acres of tropical landscaping, including a family-friendly layout and an adults-only Serenity pool.
Choose The Marker for variety — families and couples can find a pool area that suits their needs.
Eden House features a single outdoor pool and a hot tub in a garden-like courtyard.
Eden House suits travelers prioritizing a small, peaceful pool environment over multiple pool choices.
The Marker includes a 24-hour fitness center with Peloton and Hydrow equipment and provides access to a sister property's beach and spa.
The Marker works for guests who want a robust fitness setup and the option of a larger spa experience through a sister property.
Eden House emphasizes relaxed on-property time and easy walking access to Old Town bars and evening events.
Pick Eden House for quieter evenings and a low-key stay; choose The Marker for more fitness and spa options.

Multiple family-friendly pools, family rooms and on-site activities make The Marker the easier choice for families.

The Marker sits beside the Historic Seaport with waterfront dining and direct harbor access.

Eden House's individually decorated rooms and long-running local reputation appeal to travelers who want character over a conventional resort.

Eden House offers a small garden-and-pool footprint and a more intimate atmosphere for a low-key Key West visit.
The Marker — it has two family pools, a separate kids/family-friendly pool area, and family-room options; Eden House is smaller and quieter with a single pool.
The Marker is directly beside the Key West Historic Seaport; Eden House is in Old Town within walking distance of harborfront attractions but not immediately waterfront.
The Marker’s daily resort fee includes access to the beach and spa at the sister Southernmost Beach Resort; Eden House’s listing notes a health/beauty spa nearby but does not publish an on-site named spa.
Yes — both are within walking distance of Duval Street and Old Town attractions.
Explore how The Marker Key West Harbor Resort stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·