
The Marker Key West Harbor Resort
Best for families and guests who want multiple pools, a dedicated adults-only pool and private balconies with soaking tubs in Old Town.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
The Marker Key West Harbor Resort is a 4-star, family-friendly waterfront hotel in the Historic Seaport with three pools, a poolside restaurant (Starboard) and 96 rooms with private balconies and soaking tubs. Hyatt Centric Key West Resort and Spa is a 4-star branded waterfront resort on the marina near Duval Street, aimed at travelers who want Hyatt-recognition, a marina location and an on-site full-service spa and restaurant.
Updated

Best for families and guests who want multiple pools, a dedicated adults-only pool and private balconies with soaking tubs in Old Town.

Best for travelers who prefer a recognized Hyatt flag, a marina setting and an on-site full-service spa.
When The Marker wins: Choose The Marker if you want an Old Town, seaport-side resort with three distinct pools (including a tucked-away Serenity adults-only pool), an on-site family-friendly waterfront restaurant (Starboard), and rooms that all include private balconies and soaking tubs.
When Hyatt Centric wins: Pick Hyatt Centric when you value the Hyatt brand, a marina/dockside location close to Duval Street and an on-site full-service spa plus a larger resort identity with meeting rooms and marina access.
Bottom line: Both are 4-star, waterfront Key West resorts in the Old Town/seaport area. The Marker leans toward a compact, family-forward property focused on pools, balconies and in-room soaking tubs; Hyatt Centric offers brand recognition, a spa and marina-side amenities — choose based on whether pools and in-room features (Marker) or brand/spa/marina access (Hyatt Centric) matter more to your trip.
| Category | The Marker Key West Harbor Resort | Hyatt Centric Key West Resort and Spa |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Waterfront Old Town resort with tropical gardens and multiple pools (family-friendly with an adults-only Serenity pool). | Branded waterfront resort near the marina and Duval Street with a business/meeting orientation and full-service spa. |
| Location (neighborhood) | Key West Historic Seaport / Old Town (200 William St). | Marina area / near Duval Street (601 Front St). |
| Size (guest rooms) | 96 guestrooms and suites. | 120 rooms (supplier listing). |
| Ages / audience | All ages welcome; family-friendly with kid-friendly pools and family programming. | All ages welcome (not adults-only). |
| Pools | Three outdoor pools, including two family pools and a dedicated adults-only Serenity pool; poolside cocktail service. | One outdoor pool and poolside bar (supplier listing shows one outdoor pool). |
| Restaurants & bars | One onsite restaurant/bar: Starboard (American seafood, poolside, 7:30 AM–6:00 PM) plus a poolside bar. | One main restaurant (Four Flamingos Key West) with ocean-view dining and a bar/lounge and poolside bar; room service during limited hours. |
| Spa & wellness | No standalone on-site spa; resort fee includes access to beach and spa facilities at sister property Southernmost Beach Resort; 24-hour fitness center with Peloton and Hydrow onsite. | Full-service spa on site plus 24-hour fitness facilities and spa treatment rooms. |
| Known for | Private balconies, soaking tubs in every room, three pools and close access to the Historic Seaport and excursions. | Hyatt brand recognition, marina/dock access and proximity to Duval Street and Mallory Square. |
| Meetings & events | Garden Meeting Room (approx. 655 sq ft, capacity up to 70) plus outdoor event spaces and poolside wedding options (up to ~100 guests). | Business center and meeting rooms (2 meeting rooms listed); express check-out and some event facilities. |
| Parking & access | Onsite covered self-parking for a fee (quoted $44/night by the hotel). | Self parking available onsite (surcharge; supplier lists uncovered self-parking fee). |
The Marker sits beside the Key West Historic Seaport in Old Town (200 William St), steps from the marina and close to Duval Street and Mallory Square.
Best if you want Old Town seaport access and to be within walking reach of waterfront attractions.
Hyatt Centric is a branded waterfront resort near Key West’s marina and Duval Street (601 Front St), positioned for both leisure and meetings.
Best if you want a recognized hotel brand with marina-side positioning close to Duval Street.
The Marker has 96 guestrooms and suites, and every room includes a private balcony and a soaking tub.
Choose The Marker for balcony rooms and the consistent in-room feature of a soaking tub.
Hyatt Centric lists about 120 air-conditioned rooms with private furnished balconies and standard Hyatt amenities.
Hyatt Centric offers a wider documented variety of room types and ocean-view options under the Hyatt product standards.
The Marker’s single onsite venue is Starboard Restaurant & Bar, a waterfront, poolside American seafood restaurant open for breakfast and lunch.
The Marker keeps dining straightforward and daytime-focused around its poolside, waterfront restaurant and bar.
Hyatt Centric’s supplier listing highlights Four Flamingos Key West (ocean-view American cuisine) plus a bar/lounge and poolside bar.
Hyatt Centric offers an on-site restaurant with ocean-view dining and the added convenience of limited room service.
The Marker’s headline amenity is its three outdoor pools set in tropical gardens, including an adults-only Serenity pool.
If multiple pool options (family pools plus a private adults-only pool) matter, The Marker is focused on that experience.
Hyatt Centric offers an outdoor pool and direct marina/dock access as part of its waterfront offering.
Hyatt Centric is the pick if you want marina access and a single pool with dockside atmosphere rather than multiple on-property pools.
The Marker provides a 24-hour fitness center with Peloton and Hydrow equipment and gives guests beach and spa access at a sister property via the resort fee.
Good for fitness-focused travelers who don’t require an on-site full-service spa but do want nearby spa/beach access and vibrant evening options.
Hyatt Centric features an on-site full-service spa and 24-hour fitness facilities, plus close proximity to Key West nightlife.
Hyatt Centric is better if you want an on-site spa plus Hyatt-level meeting and concierge services while still being close to Key West nightlife.

Three pools including dedicated family pools, kids welcome and family-friendly poolside dining at Starboard.

Hyatt Centric offers the Hyatt flag, a full-service spa and a marina-side profile that appeals to brand-loyal guests.

Multiple pools (two family pools + adults-only Serenity pool) give more on-site swim options than the single pool listed for Hyatt Centric.

Hyatt Centric lists a full-service spa with treatment rooms on site, while The Marker directs guests to a sister property for spa access.
The Marker is more explicitly family-focused with two family pools, a separate adults-only Serenity pool, and family-friendly dining and programming.
Hyatt Centric lists a full-service spa on site; The Marker provides beach and spa access at its sister property (Southernmost Beach Resort) rather than a named on-site spa.
Both properties are in Old Town Key West and within short walks of Duval Street and Mallory Square; each supplier listing highlights easy walking access to these Old Town attractions.
Yes. Both properties welcome guests of all ages; The Marker emphasizes family pools and kids-friendly amenities while Hyatt Centric is not an adults-only property.
Explore how The Marker Key West Harbor Resort stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·